|
Lost Boys: African American Males Committing Suicide
Ron Stodghill, II - Essence Nov 1998
It seemed like a perfect night. The air was crisp and the
sun had begun its slow retreat behind the snowcapped Denver mountains. As Les
Franklin cruised home in his black Porsche on October 19, 1990, the
then-51-year-old IBM executive reflected on what had been a grueling day:
meetings, briefings and even a run-in with the press.
But the didn't take any of it to heart. Truth was, he loved
being a power broker, sitting on umpteen boards and making things happen about
town. Musing over the details of his busy life, Les pulled into the garage of
his sprawling split-level home in the affluent enclave of Gun Club Green, and
called the name he had called so many times before: "Shaka!"
Hearing that greeting, Franklin's 16-year-old son, Shaka,
named after the great Zulu warrior, would scurry out of his room and meet his
Pops with a big bear hug. It was a kind of ritual, something Franklin could
count on at the end of each day. But tonight, oddly, Shaka made no response.
Figuring his son was deep into some computer game or new rap CD, Franklin
stepped into Shaka's bedroom.
What he saw brought him to his knees. There, lying on the
bloodstained carpet, was his beloved son, with a black .38 pistol between his
legs and a gunshot wound to the head.
"Shaka!!!" This is a story about how a boy's death
transformed a man's life: a story about pain and denial, ambitious parents and
sensitive children. Ultimately, though, it's about the disturbing rise in
suicide among young Black men, and the mysterious emotional odyssey that leads
to such a tragic finale.
Suicide, long considered taboo in our culture, is
increasingly becoming a critical issue for African-American families. According
to a recent study by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) in
Atlanta, the suicide rate among Blacks ages 10 to 19 more than doubled between
1980 and 1995. The increase was more pronounced among Black males than females;
for brothers ages 15 to 19, the rate of suicide soared 146 percent.
This troubling trend belies the age-old myth that Blacks
are generally not inclined to turn to suicide -- that we somehow harbor an
innate resilience or deep spirituality that shields us from the feelings of
hopelessness that compel suicides. The pervasive belief has even worked its way
into comic monologues: "Why don't Blacks commit suicide? It's hard to kill
yourself jumping from a basement window...."
Theories behind the sharp rise in Black suicides vary from
the breakdown of the family to easier access to alcohol, drugs and guns. One of
the most prominent, and controversial, explanations is an inability of
middle-class African-Americans to cope with their success and the accompanying
stress. According to Tonji Durant, Ph.D., lead author of the CDC report, "Black
youths in upwardly mobile families may experience stress associated with their
new social environments. Alternatively, these youths may adopt the coping
behaviors of the larger society, in which suicide is more commonly used in
response to depression and hopelessness."
However, this movin'-on-up reasoning has not been
buttressed by much data. (In fact, the CDC did not even consider the economic
status of the suicide victims in its study.) Still, there is some compelling
evidence, both scientific and anecdotal. One Columbia University study of child
and adolescent suicides in the New York City area, published in 1996, concluded
that, unlike White and Hispanic youth, Black suicide victims tend to come from
higher socioeconomic backgrounds than Blacks in the general population.
Dr. Carl Bell, a psychiatrist at the Community Mental
Health Council in Chicago, says that while suicide among all races is rooted in
clinical depression, middle-class Blacks often suffer an acute sense of
isolation that puts them at higher risk. "Many Blacks no longer accept you, and
Whites don't want you either," Bell says. "As for young Black men, society
definitely doesn't have any place for them -- except prison."
Others argue that, for Blacks, suicide among privileged
kids and homicide disadvantaged kids are two sides of the same coin. "The kid
who walks out the house with a semiautomatic gun and confronts another kid armed
with a weapon -- we don't call that suicide," says Stephen Thomas, director of
the Institute for Minority Health Research at Emory University's School of
Public Health in Atlanta. "But it's self-destructive behavior that has a place
in the same debate."
Still other experts suggest that upwardly mobile Black
parents may be spending too much time grooming their children to assimilate into
mainstream society and too little time teaching them moral and spiritual values.
"Our children are hungry for spiritually based structure in their lives," says
Dr. Frederick Phillips, a psychologist and the president of Progressive Life
Center, a Washington, D.C.-based behavioral-health and child-welfare agency.
Geoffrey Canada, president of the nonprofit Rheedlen
Centers for Children and Families in New York City, adds: "In working so hard to
create opportunities and erase pressure for their children, parents may also
eliminate some of the obstacles children need to discover who they are as
people, as well as their sense of belonging and importance to the family."
Sandra Moore, who walked in on her teenage son four years
ago as he was about to stab himself in the stomach with a knife, says: "I was so
busy trying to get my doctorate -- which I thought would secure our financial
stability -- that I almost lost my son in the process. We shouldn't be so smug
as to believe that just because we live in the suburbs nothing can happen to our
children." A director for a family literacy program in Atlanta, Moore, 42,
shares her son's story in her upcoming book Mama! Can't You Hear My Cry?
If only someone had heard Shaka's cry. Eight years after
his death, few friends or family members can say with any certainty that Shaka
cried out to them at all. But it will always be Les Franklin who bears the
heaviest burden of guilt; he believes that even though his son's cry for help
was as silent as his own breath, paternal instinct should have prompted him into
action.
For Shaka, the downward spiral began when he was just 6
years old and his father divorced his mother, Cherllyn. The breakup occurred
when Les was transferred from Denver to Connecticut, a move Cherllyn resisted.
Though he never discussed it with the children, Les realized that he and his
wife were growing apart, and that it was time for them to separate. To Shaka's
dismay, Cherllyn agreed to let Les move Shaka and his older brother, Jamon, to
Connecticut without her. "Shaka felt abandoned by his mother," says Les. "And he
never forgave me for the divorce."
Several events followed that would devastate Shaka, pushing
him further into despair. That same year his paternal grandmother, with whom he
had always had a close, loving relationship, died. A few years later, after Les
and the boys had returned to Denver, Les's girlfriend Marianne moved into their
home, shattering Shaka's hope that his parents would reunite.
"He never really accepted me," says Marianne, now Les's
wife, a soft-spoken woman who admits that her reserved nature strikes some as
aloof "Sometimes I think I should have worked harder to get close to him. But I
didn't want to push things."
In 1987 Les was diagnosed with diabetes, and about a year
later Shaka learned that his mother, whose breast cancer had been in remission,
was dying from the disease. It was during this period that Shaka's brother,
Jamon, noticed a change in him.
They had always been tight, but lately Shaka seemed to be
avoiding him. He wasn't cold, just distant. Jamon told their mother about it and
she validated his gut feelings. "She said Shaka wasn't dealing with her illness
very well at all -- that he was real depressed over it," Jamon, now 29, recalls.
(Cherllyn died on March 2, 1991, five months after Shaka.)
Les's close friend Damani Camara now says he also saw
something strangely hollow in Shaka's eyes. "He was at my house visiting my son
one day, and I took a picture of them together," Camara recalls. "When I got the
picture developed and looked at it closely, I thought, This boy looks so sad to
me." Camara called Les with his observation, but the proud father resisted the
notion, saying, "No, he doesn't. No, he doesn't."
"My sons and I were always close," Les recalls, "and we
promised to come together whenever things got too tough for us to handle alone.
But Shaka broke his promise."
Today, Les Franklin still dreams about his Shaka. He sees
him running, clad in his brown football uniform, number 70, diving to catch a
pass. He sees him sitting quietly at his computer and glancing up with a
satisfied smile. Or laughing as he walks home with friends after school, dressed
in baggy jeans and carrying a backpack full of books and CDs.
He wishes the dreams would continue, but they always end
the same: with Shaka discovering the Smith & Wesson snub-nosed pistol tucked
away in his father's closet, carrying it back into his bedroom, and leaving the
world with no explanation save a carved wooden heart with "Love Shaka" written
on it in purple ink.
To begin to give some meaning to the tragedy and his own
life, Les retired from IBM a week after Shaka's death. He knew that when he
stepped out in public, people no longer saw a wealthy, successful man, but a man
tormented by his son's suicide.
Indeed, had Shaka not been the child of a high-ranking IBM
executive -- a privileged kid with an indoor swimming pool and a social life
teeming with friends and activities -- it is unlikely that his death would have
hit the front page of local newspapers and been the buzz for months, everywhere
from the cocktail circuit in Denver to barbershops in the 'hood. Sometimes it
takes a fallen hero to get the masses to reflect on their own lives. Shaka's
suicide, like a stone tossed into a quiet pond, caused a ripple effect as
parents across the city were forced to confront the potential time bombs ticking
inside their own children.
For Les, the thrill of corporate deal-making was quickly
replaced by a deeper desire to spend more time with his family, as well as to
help other children cope with the kind of depression that took his son's life.
In 1990, with the help of his wife, he launched the Shaka Franklin Foundation
for Youth, a nonprofit organization in Colorado aimed at preventing child and
teen suicide through youth and family programs. "I'm determined to make sure the
surprise I got is something no other parent has to live through," he says.
Franklin realizes, though, that his nascent foundation is
only as strong as the households of the children receiving its services. Experts
agree that in order to help avoid such a tragedy, parents first must reorganize
their priorities to make their children's well-being central. Squeezing in an
hour or so of "quality time" might ease a busy parent's guilt, but it may not be
enough for children who are inclined to reveal the most when it's least
expected.
It's also important to find creative ways to relate to your
children, whether it's getting them to help you prepare a meal or wash the car,
inviting their friends out for a movie, quizzing them on their schoolwork, or
simply sharing with them some of the events of your day.
Parents need to engage their kids in constant dialogue; if
there is the slightest sign of depression or stress (see sidebar, below),
parents should identify and address the causes. And last, you must understand
that the pressures you dealt with as a child are often minor compared with what
many kids face today. It's critical to help young people understand they aren't
facing those struggles alone. "Every generation of children deals with another
layer of pressure both socially and academically," says Phillips. "Our children
today need us now more than ever."
WARNING SIGNS
A recent Commonwealth Fund survey of more than 3,000
American boys in grades 5 to 12 found that one in five Black boys had thought of
killing themselves. Parents need to be aware of the symptoms of depression that
often precede suicide attempts. They include: * exaggerated feelings of sadness,
anxiety, hopelessness; * decreased interest in activities or people; *
difficulty concentrating; * indecisiveness; * sleeping or appetite disturbances;
* recurring feelings of worthlessness; * loss of energy or motivation; and *
thoughts about suicide.
Additional warning signs are a desire to give one's
possessions way, suicide threats and previous suicide attempts. If your child
exhibits any of these behaviors, talk to him and seek help immediately from a
trained mental-health counselor. Also contact one or more of the following
organizations for information and referrals:
* Association of Black Psychologist, P.O. Box 55999,
Washington DC 20040-5999
* Black Psychiatrists of America, 866 Carlston Ave.,
Oakland CA 94610
* National Foundation for Depressive Illness, P.O. Box
2257, New York NY 10116; (800) 245-4340
* American Foundation for Suicide Prevention, 120 Wall St.,
22nd Fl., New York NY 10005
* The Shaka Franklin Foundation for Youth, 8101 E.
Dartmouth Ave., #11, Denver CO 80231
COPYRIGHT 1998 Essence Communications, Inc. in association
with The Gale Group and LookSmart.
COPYRIGHT 2000 Gale Group
http://www.findarticles.com/cf_dls/m1264/n7_v29/21253796/p1/article.jhtml


Back To The Top
SMHAI Home |
About Suicide |
About Mental Health |
Suicide Prevention |
Suicide Survivors
Suicide Attempters |
Self-Injury - Cutters |
Crisis |
Donate |
SMHAI Library |
Online Support & Resources
Speakers & Presentations |
Memorials, Remebrances & Celebrations Of Life |
Healing Music
Suggested Reading - Survivors |
Suggested Reading - Attempters & Self-Injurers |
Mental Health Pros.
Upcoming Events |
Dr. Roerich's Welcome |
Ann Gay's Welcome |
Legal & About SMHAI
Privacy Policy |
Copyright Notice |
Awards Honoring SMHAI |
SMHAI Awards Program |
Contact
© SMHAI 2004 - 2006 All Rights Reserved. No copying or redistribution without expressed written permission of SMHAI.
Logo Design by Allen R. Jacobson. Site launched July 01, 2004.
|